Covering figures as diverse as hobson, luxembourg, hilferding, bukharin, lenin, frank, wallerstein, emmanuel and warren, as well as marx himself, it analyses how marxists have accounted for. Postkeynesian theorists and the theory of economic development what is the contribution of the postkeynesians to the theory of economic development. Ostensibly, these three thinkers could not be more different. In underdeveloped countries, however, there was no competitive stage, so they are frozen at a low level of production and income. Marxs theory of value and distribution receives detailed attention, followed by his models of capital accumulation and economic crisis. Hilferding realized that the development of the stock exchange was parallel to the development of standardized derivative exchanges. He considers himself to be an eclectic economist who dips into a range of economic theory pragmatically. Marxist theories of imperialism cankaya universitesi. Rudolf hilferding 10 august 1877 11 february 1941 was an austrianborn marxist economist, leading socialist theorist, politician and chief theoretician for the social democratic party of germany spd during the weimar republic, almost universally recognized as the spds foremost theoretician of his century, and a physician. Various constraints imposed by nature, markets, the government, etc. The paper compares joseph schumpeter, emil lederer and rudolf hilferding with respect to their visions concerning economic development, technology, credit and business cycles.
Marx had not given military spending a central role in the theory of capital. I havent read hilferding s book myself, but its mentioned in howardkings history of marxian economics and referred to as one of the most influential texts in the history of marxian economic theory. This approach assumes that economic decisions are made for a reason. Assume that with probability s, the worker and firm will receive an adverse, matchspecific shock that causes them to separate. Jan 23, 2020 hilferding was a propounder for the economic reading of karl marx identifying with the austromarxian group. Hobson in 1902 and by the austrian marxist economist rudolf hilferding in his 1910 book finance capital. Marxist theories of imperialism a critical survey this seminal account of marxist theories of imperialism is now appearing in a revised and expanded edition. By contrast, while influential on lippmanns analyses, lenin is not a preneoliberal because he hails from an entirely unique philosophical and economic theoretic trajectory though he did incorporate some of hilferding. The current economicfinancial crisis requires, in my opinion, a return to the. But hilferding s approach to derivatives has been left untouched. Politicians rely on studies of government spending, tax collections, money supply, and. Rudolf hilferding s theory of finance capitalism and today. Preface in the following pages an attempt will be made to arrive at a scientific understanding of the economic characteristics of the latest phase of capitalist development.
The highest stage of capitalism, gives a very valuable theoretical analysis of the latest phase of capitalist development, as. A study of the latest phase of capitalist development economic history, author rudolf hilferding, publisher, isbn 0415379288,9780415379281, year. Recent heterodox economic literature makes reference to hilferdings finance. The theory of finance capitalism developed by rudolf hilferding 1981, originally published in 1910 provides a unique approach for interpreting and evaluating the evolution of world financial markets and the world economy since the collapse of the bretton woods system of. The theory of finance capitalism developed by rudolf hilferding 1981, originally published in 1910 provides a unique approach for interpreting and evaluating the evolution of world financial markets and the world economy since the collapse of the bretton woods system of fixed exchange rates in the early 1970s. Howardking mention that kautsky considered it to be the completion of capital.
But hilferdings approach to derivatives has been left untouched. This theoretical association abolishes labor value theory from the analytical. Liberalism was in reality a destructive force involving the overthrow. The previously separate spheres of industrial, commercial and bank capital are now brought under the common direction of high finance, in which the masters of industry and of the banks are united in a close personal association. Sotiropoulos kingston university london, uk abstract rudolf hilferding is a leading marxist scholar. This question may seem an unusual one to ask at first sight. The influence of the currencybanking debate on early. Traditional economic theory points out, that economic crises, are associated with theories of economic cycles. Based on bagehots theory, it can be concluded that financial system plays a role in fostering economic growth. Economic crisis an economic crisis is a situation in which the reproduction of an economic unit is suddenly compromised, typically when it is unable to meet its contractual obligations. Dec 19, 2019 hilferding capital financeiro pdf 22 mar. In the past fifty years the advanced tools of economic. Rudolf hilferdings theory of finance capitalism and today.
Hilferding was a proponent of the economic reading of karl marx identifying with the. It is true that there is a gap in economic literature concerning the influence that hilferding s work might have exercised on schumpeter, and with the exception of very few papers for example, fritz and haulman 1987 no research. In that event, a firm has to find a new employee, and a worker has to find a new employer. Finance capital signifies the unification of capital. Finance capital, written in 1910 by rudolf hilferding, is normally understood to be. Three theories of underdevelopment progress in political. For instance, all three used similar arguments to emphasize the link between economic development and. However, it is somewhat noteworthy to find such a similarity between theorists from.
Hilferdings influence on schumpeter munich personal repec. It is interesting to note that, in his early writings, lederer had adopted and extended many of hilferdings and tuganbaranowskys theses. These are three apparently distinct strands of economics, yet they have a common motivation. Economic theory is a broad concept for the explanation and understanding of the movement of goods in a market. The writing of the article was motivated by the publication, the previous year, of the third volume of.
It is true that there is a gap in economic literature. Rudolf hilferding the history of economic thought website. I m p e r i a l i s m t h e hi g h e s t s o f ca p i t a. Economic development schumpeter started his the theory of economic development with a treatise of. Since the industrial revolution, however, we have entered a strange new world in which economic theory is of little use in understanding differences in income across societies, or the future income in any specific society. A recent work cesarano, 2006 has observed the evolution of the dialectics between economic history and economic theory, for example. Hilferding also participated in the crises debate disputing marx. Varian why is economic theory a worthwhile thing to do. Complementary nonquantity theory approaches to money. The subjective approach to value theory is discussed with reference to neoclassical economics. In other words, the object is to bring these characteristics within the theoretical system of classical political economy which begins with william petty and finds its supreme expression in marx. Rudolf hilferding on english mercantilism history of. It is true that there is a gap in economic literature concerning the influence. The intellectual aspiration of the paper is to cover both theoretical aspects associated with political economy, the role of the state and economic policy, especially in the era of crisis.
Part of the palgrave studies in the history of economic thought book series phet abstract rudolf hilferding entered the history of economic thought in the first place as the author of finance capital. Jun 01, 2014 the schumpeterhilferding nexus 143 schumpeter stressed certain actors. An inquiry into profits, capital, credit, interest and the business. Finance capital, written in 1910 by rudolf hilferding, is normally understood to be a marxian work.
Karl marx and the close of his system mises institute. A crisis may be generalised from one unit to the system as a whole, with the crisis being transmitted through a. But, in the end, its emphasis is on formal modeling. Utility, wealth, value, commodity, labour, land, capital, are the elements of the subject. The great economist takes on karl marx, and his fundamental failure to understand the workings of the capital market and its relationship to value.
The first is to study the links between the new economic theories, this is, the new trade theory, the new growth theory and the new economic geography. The export of capital and the struggle for economic territory. A political economy viewpoint of the struggles in the left 19001933 and the modern revival. Rudolf hilferding 10 august 1877 11 february 1941 was an austrianborn marxist. It will, of course, involve more reading and discussion of the behavioral evidence and psychological foundations of our assumptions than do other theory or non theory economics courses. Social facts are the result of human con duct, economic facts result from economic conduct and the latter may be defined. The criticism was devastating, so much so that a leading marxist responded, and thus herein is rudolf hilferding s response.
One obvious answer is that it is a challenging intellectual enterprise and. Pdf on jan 1, 2012, alin croitoru and others published schumpeter, j. Their theoretical investigations, in a great number of thematic areas and concepts, seem to converge significantly. The subject matter of economics or economic theory has been variously defined. Contending economic theories online university of the left. The oscar meyer collection has a bit on hilferding. Mar 11, 2020 rudolf hilferding was the first marxist scholar to draw attention to the emergence of finance in rudolf hilferding ed, o capital financeiro. State political power and finance economic power become eventually the two faces of the same coin.
Rudolf hilferding on english mercantilism the early days of english political economy 1911 dupuit and walras on the natural monopoly in transport industries. Rudolf hilferdings theory of finance capital springerlink. Theoretical economic concepts typically have scientific backing or studies to prove or disprove a stated hypothesis. In the struggle against economic mercantilism and political absolutism, the bourgeoisie was the champion of opposition to the state. Economics discussion paper 20123 hilferding on derivatives. In the following pages an attempt will be made to arrive at a scientific understanding of the economic characteristics of the latest phase of capitalist development. This is the first english translation of one of the classical works of marxist economic theory. Capital, in 1910, a reassessment of hilferdings contributions to the understanding of the capitalism of his time turns out to be essential, in spite of certain errors,1 for the understanding of contemporary events. Schumpeters theory of economic development appeared. This is because a great deal of postkeynesian economic theorizing. Pdf rudolf hilferding on english mercantilism researchgate. There has been a lot of controversy among economist about the true content of economic theory or its subject matter. Schumpeter, lederer and hilferding on economic development.
By contrast, while influential on lippmanns analyses, lenin is not a preneoliberal because he hails from an entirely unique philosophical and economictheoretic trajectory though he did incorporate some of hilferding. But in the relation of bank to industrial capital we only observe in their most mature form the same relationships that can be discerned in the more elementary forms of money and. National governments also have an interest in theories of economics. Hilferding s approach is understood in this paper as a major revision of marxs conceptual understanding of the capitalist mode of production and, therefore, as a paradigm shift within marxian economic theory. Radical economics, marxist economics and marxs economics issue. It is true that there is a gap in economic literature concerning the influence that hilferdings work might have exercised on schumpeter, and with the exception of very few papers e. In 1911 rudolf hilferding, the author of the famous book finance capital. Pdf in 1911 rudolf hilferding, the author of the famous book finance capital. Recent heterodox economic literature makes reference to hilferdings finance capital and lenins imperialism as early insights on the phenomenon of financialization of capital.
Popularizer and propounder of the economic reading of karl marx, hilferding was one of the leading marxian theorists of his day, identified with the austromarxian group. Marxian and nonmarxian foundations of rudolf hilferding. Marxs capital contained, in his view, a classical, comprehensive analysis of traditional capitalism, which should be complemented with the analysis of new. The science of political economy rests upon a few notions of an apparently simple character. The previously separate spheres of industrial, commercial and bank capital are now brought under the common direction of high finance, in which the masters of industry and of. Nikos stravelakis department of economics national and kapodistrian university of athens abstract. Radical economics, marxist economics and marxs economics. Rudolf hilferdings theory of finance capitalism and todays. Hilferding understood the economic significance that derivative. He was the first to put forward the theory of organized capitalism.
Hilferding and tuganbaranowsky delivered theories of economic fluctuations focusing on the role of disproportional growth between production sectors. According to adam smith economics enquires into the nature and causes of the wealth of nations. A political economy viewpoint of the struggles in the. Hence, the crisis would only be overcome if the capacity of these companies to accumulate capital, as well as the degree of confidence in expectations to induce investment in capital assets, were recuperated. The objective approach to value theory is discussed with respect to classical political economy and the labour theory of value and the sraffian revival of classical value theory in the twentieth century. Theory of imperialism concerns the global systemic outcomes of the tendency for the rate of profit to fall in the capitalist system, and the objective impact of the consequences of those dynamics, and countertendencies in the world economy which are now generally associated with marxian economics.
Hilferding was a propounder for the economic reading of karl marx identifying with the austromarxian group. Rudolf hilferding entered the history of economic thought in the first place as the author of finance capital. One of the most revolutionary aspects of hilferdings theory is the. Apr 26, 2016 the marxist theory of imperialism derives not directly from marx but from lenins application of marxs method to a study of the economic and political developments which brought about the first world war in his famous work, imperialism. The japanese society for the history of economic thought. Economics discussion paper 20123 hilferding on derivatives dimitris p.
It is true that there is a gap in economic literature concerning the influence that hilferdings work might have exercised on schumpeter, and with the exception of very few papers for example, fritz and haulman 1987 no research. Fritz and haulman 1987 no research seems to have been done on this. Other theoretical thinking which dominated during nineteen century included those of karl max on the role of finance capital on economic growth hilferding, 1981. Thepredominanceofmonopolies within the bourgeois class is the distinguishing feature, of contemporary capitalism. Hilferding model, from which lenins imperialism is derived, has very little or nothing to do with marxs economics but much to do with the neoclassical theory of monopoly and oligopoly. Then the post1883 development of marxian economics in germany and russia is outlined, with particular emphasis on the revisionist controversy, the economic interpretation of imperialist rivalry, and the. Recent heterodox economic literature makes reference to hilferding s finance capital and lenins imperialism as early insights on the phenomenon of financialization of capital. Apr 30, 2018 jonas zoninsein concentrates on the theory of monopoly capital, which has its roots in hilferdings work, presenting a critique of this economic principle that plays an outstanding role in current explanations of how the capitalist mode of production operates in the twentieth century. Hilferdings approach is understood in this paper as a major revision of marxs methodological perspective and conceptual understanding of the capitalist mode of production and, therefore, as a paradigm shift within marxian economic theory. In this regard ideas which became dominant in the left during the first decades of the previous century are applied in the explanation of the current crisis, as well as the. Hilferding s finance capital and freebanking theory steven horwitz it is not that unusual in the history of economic thought to find a the orist whose work parallels the analysis of modern authors.
1082 62 676 580 693 295 772 1152 55 235 1295 1460 1515 54 1513 324 1273 913 421 279 243 1006 4 595 1308 808 762 1037 574 467 510 1458 1021